1 Indicator category

[Fill by hand, needs decision by Council]

2 Indicator name

Fish Productivity Indicators

Includes variable(s): Acadian redfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -logrs_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Acadian redfish -rs_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -rs-Assessment, Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey, American plaice -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, American plaice -logrs_anom-Assessment, American plaice -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, American plaice -rs_anom-Assessment, American plaice -rs-Assessment, American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey, Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment, Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, ATLANTIC COD_Survey, Atlantic herring -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -logrs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Atlantic herring -rs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -rs-Assessment, Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -logrs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -rs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -rs-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -logrs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -rs_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -rs-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, Black sea bass -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -logrs_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Black sea bass -rs_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -rs-Assessment, Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, BLACK SEA BASS_Survey, Butterfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -logrs_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Butterfish -rs_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -rs-Assessment, Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment, Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment, Haddock -rs-Assessment, Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, HADDOCK_Survey, NE LME ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey, NE LME AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey, NE LME ATLANTIC COD_Survey, NE LME BLACK SEA BASS_Survey, NE LME HADDOCK_Survey, NE LME POLLOCK_Survey, NE LME RED HAKE_Survey, NE LME SILVER HAKE_Survey, NE LME SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey, NE LME WHITE HAKE_Survey, NE LME WINDOWPANE_Survey, NE LME WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey, NE LME WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey, NE LME YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey, Pollock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Pollock -logrs_anom-Assessment, Pollock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Pollock -rs_anom-Assessment, Pollock -rs-Assessment, Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, POLLOCK_Survey, RED HAKE_Survey, Scup -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Scup -logrs_anom-Assessment, Scup -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Scup -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Scup -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Scup -rs_anom-Assessment, Scup -rs-Assessment, Scup -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Scup -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, SCUP_Survey, SILVER HAKE_Survey, Spiny dogfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -logrs_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -rs_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -rs-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, Summer flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Summer flounder -rs_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -rs-Assessment, Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey, Tilefish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -logrs_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Tilefish -rs_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -rs-Assessment, Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, White hake -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, White hake -logrs_anom-Assessment, White hake -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, White hake -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, White hake -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, White hake -rs_anom-Assessment, White hake -rs-Assessment, White hake -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, White hake -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, WHITE HAKE_Survey, WINDOWPANE_Survey, Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -rs-Assessment, Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey, WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey, Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment, Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment, YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

3 Indicator brief description

Amount of small fish produced per large fish biomass over time

4 Indicator visualization

The small fish per large fish anomaly indicator, derived from NEFSC bottom trawl survey data, shows that productivity has been declining in the Mid-Atlantic region since 2003. A similar analysis based on stock assessment model outputs (recruitment per spawning stock biomass anomaly) for stocks primarily inhabiting the Mid-Atlantic region also shows a decline in productivity. The indicators show great variability in the Gulf of Maine and Georges Bank, with both regions being below average for much of the past decade.

## [1] "Assessment variable includes GB and GOM. See plot for EPU = GB."

5 Indicator documentation

5.1 Are indicators available for others to use (data downloadable)?

## Yes

5.1.1 Where can indicators be found?

## Data: https://noaa-edab.github.io/ecodata/index.html 
## Description:  https://noaa-edab.github.io/catalog/productivity_anomaly.html 
## Technical documentation:  https://noaa-edab.github.io/tech-doc/productivity_anomaly.html

5.1.2 How often are they updated? Are future updates likely?

[need sequential look at datasets for update frequency. Future requires judgement]

5.1.3 Who is the contact?

5.2 Gather indicator statistics

5.2.1 Units

Indicator

Units

Acadian redfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -rs-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

American plaice -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

American plaice -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -rs-Assessment

NA

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

ATLANTIC COD_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Atlantic herring -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -rs-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -rs-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -rs-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -rs-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Butterfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -rs-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -rs-Assessment

NA

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

HADDOCK_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME ATLANTIC COD_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME HADDOCK_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME POLLOCK_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME RED HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME SILVER HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME WHITE HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME WINDOWPANE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

NE LME YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Pollock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Pollock -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -rs-Assessment

NA

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

POLLOCK_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

RED HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Scup -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Scup -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -rs-Assessment

NA

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

SCUP_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

SILVER HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Spiny dogfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -rs-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -rs-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Tilefish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -rs-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

White hake -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

White hake -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -rs-Assessment

NA

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

WHITE HAKE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

WINDOWPANE_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -rs-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NA

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NA

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

anomaly (r/s)

5.2.2 Length of time series, start and end date, periodicity

General overview: No response

Indicator specifics:

Indicator

EPU

StartYear

EndYear

NumYears

MissingYears

Acadian redfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2021

42

0

ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

American plaice -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

MAB

1989

1996

2

6

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Southern New England

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Southern New England

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

1981

2022

42

0

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2022

43

0

ATLANTIC COD_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

ATLANTIC COD_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

Atlantic herring -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -rs-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

1980

2022

43

0

Atlantic mackerel -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -rs-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Atlantic wolffish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Black sea bass -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

1988

2022

35

0

Black sea bass -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

Black sea bass -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

1988

2022

35

0

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

1988

2022

35

0

Black sea bass -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

Black sea bass -rs-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

1989

2022

34

0

BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

MAB

1983

2019

37

0

Butterfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -rs-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

1989

2022

34

0

Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -rs-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

1980

2021

42

0

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

HADDOCK_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

HADDOCK_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

NE LME ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

All

1980

2019

40

0

NE LME AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

All

1980

2019

40

0

NE LME ATLANTIC COD_Survey

All

1980

2020

41

0

NE LME BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

All

1983

2020

38

0

NE LME HADDOCK_Survey

All

1980

2019

40

0

NE LME POLLOCK_Survey

All

1980

2019

40

0

NE LME RED HAKE_Survey

All

1980

2020

35

6

NE LME SILVER HAKE_Survey

All

1980

2020

41

0

NE LME SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

All

1980

2020

41

0

NE LME WHITE HAKE_Survey

All

1982

2019

38

0

NE LME WINDOWPANE_Survey

All

1992

2020

29

0

NE LME WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

All

1980

2020

41

0

NE LME WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

All

1982

2020

39

0

NE LME YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

All

1980

2019

40

0

Pollock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

POLLOCK_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

POLLOCK_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

RED HAKE_Survey

GB

1980

2019

34

6

RED HAKE_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

34

6

RED HAKE_Survey

MAB

1980

2019

34

6

Scup -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -rs-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

1984

2022

39

0

SCUP_Survey

GB

1994

2017

3

21

SILVER HAKE_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

SILVER HAKE_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

SILVER HAKE_Survey

MAB

1980

2019

40

0

Spiny dogfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -rs-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

1980

2021

42

0

Summer flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

1982

2022

41

0

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

2003

2009

2

5

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

1980

2019

40

0

Tilefish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -rs-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

1980

2022

43

0

White hake -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -rs-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1980

2020

41

0

WHITE HAKE_Survey

GOM

1982

2019

38

0

WHITE HAKE_Survey

MAB

1982

2016

17

18

WINDOWPANE_Survey

GB

1992

2019

28

0

WINDOWPANE_Survey

GOM

1992

2019

28

0

WINDOWPANE_Survey

MAB

1992

2019

28

0

Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1981

2020

40

0

Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1981

2020

40

0

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1981

2020

40

0

Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

Winter flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -rs-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

1981

2021

41

0

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1982

2020

39

0

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

1980

2019

40

0

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

1982

2019

38

0

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

1982

2019

38

0

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

1982

2019

38

0

Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

1984

2020

37

0

Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

1984

2020

37

0

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

1984

2020

37

0

Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

1980

2020

41

0

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

1985

2020

36

0

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

1980

2019

40

0

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

1980

2019

40

0

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

1980

2019

40

0

5.2.3 Spatial location, scale and extent

General overview: No response

Indicator specifics:

Indicator

EPU

Acadian redfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -rs-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Acadian redfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

GOM

American plaice -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

American plaice -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -rs-Assessment

NE

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

American plaice -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

GB

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

GOM

AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

MAB

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -rs-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Eastern Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Southern New England

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Western Gulf of Maine

Atlantic cod -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

ATLANTIC COD_Survey

GB

ATLANTIC COD_Survey

GOM

Atlantic herring -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -rs-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic herring -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -rs-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic mackerel -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

Atlantic wolffish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -rs-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Atlantic wolffish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

Black sea bass -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -rs-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

Black sea bass -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

MAB

Butterfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -rs-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

Butterfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -rs-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -rs-Assessment

NE

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

Eastern Georges Bank

Haddock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

HADDOCK_Survey

GB

HADDOCK_Survey

GOM

NE LME ACADIAN REDFISH_Survey

All

NE LME AMERICAN PLAICE_Survey

All

NE LME ATLANTIC COD_Survey

All

NE LME BLACK SEA BASS_Survey

All

NE LME HADDOCK_Survey

All

NE LME POLLOCK_Survey

All

NE LME RED HAKE_Survey

All

NE LME SILVER HAKE_Survey

All

NE LME SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

All

NE LME WHITE HAKE_Survey

All

NE LME WINDOWPANE_Survey

All

NE LME WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

All

NE LME WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

All

NE LME YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

All

Pollock -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Pollock -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -rs-Assessment

NE

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Pollock -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

POLLOCK_Survey

GB

POLLOCK_Survey

GOM

RED HAKE_Survey

GB

RED HAKE_Survey

GOM

RED HAKE_Survey

MAB

Scup -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

Scup -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -rs-Assessment

ALL

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

Scup -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

SCUP_Survey

GB

SILVER HAKE_Survey

GB

SILVER HAKE_Survey

GOM

SILVER HAKE_Survey

MAB

Spiny dogfish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -logrs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -rs_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -rs-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

ALL

Spiny dogfish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

ALL

Summer flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

Summer flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

SUMMER FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

Tilefish -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -rs-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

Tilefish -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

White hake -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

White hake -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -rs-Assessment

NE

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

White hake -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

WHITE HAKE_Survey

GOM

WHITE HAKE_Survey

MAB

WINDOWPANE_Survey

GB

WINDOWPANE_Survey

GOM

WINDOWPANE_Survey

MAB

Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -rs-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

Winter flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

WINTER FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

WITCH FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -logr_abund_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -logrs_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -logs_biom_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -recruits_abund_lead1-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -rs_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -rs-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0_anom-Assessment

NE

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

MA

Yellowtail flounder -spawners_biom_lag0-Assessment

NE

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

GB

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

GOM

YELLOWTAIL FLOUNDER_Survey

MAB

5.2.4 Management scale: all species, FMP level, species level, can it be aggregated or separated to different scales?

[Classify by hand, note gridded data if available could be applied to different species ranges]

5.2.5 Uncertainty metrics

5.3 Are methods clearly documented to obtain source data and calculate indicators?

## Yes

5.3.1 Can the indicator be calculated from current documentation?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for current and previous methods]

5.3.2 Is code publicly available? up to date?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for current and previous methods]

5.3.3 Have methods changed over time?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for current and previous methods]

5.4 Are indicator underlying source data linked or easy to find?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for source, may require judgements]

5.4.1 Where are source data stored?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for source, may require judgement]

5.4.2 How/by whom are source data updated? Are future updates likely?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for source, may require judgement]

5.4.3 How often are they updated?

[Build link to Tech-doc, look for source, may require judgement]

6 Indicator analysis/testing or history of use

6.1 What decision or advice processes are the indicators currently used in?

The amount of young fish produced by a population tells us both about the health of individual populations and about the productivity throughout the ecosystem when we look across multiple stocks. This has implications for both managing fisheries (lower productivity often leads to lower harvest) and for other components of the ecosystem. These indicators are based on the work of Perretti [12]. We updated the data used in that analysis to describe patterns of aggregate fish productivity in the Mid-Atlantic, Georges Bank, and Gulf of Maine by evaluating changes in reproductive output relative to adult population size across multiple stocks. Both survey information and stock assessment information is used in separate indicators.

6.2 What implications of the indicators are currently listed?

The apparent decline in productivity across multiple managed species in the MAB, along with generally poor fish conditions in 2024, also suggest changing ecosystem productivity at multiple levels. During the 1990s high relative abundance of smaller bodied copepods and a lower relative abundance of Calanus finmarchicus was associated with regime shifts to higher fish recruitment [12]. The unprecedented climate signals along with the trends toward lower productivity across multiple managed species indicate a need to continually evaluate whether management reference points remain appropriate, and to evaluate if ecosystem regime shifts have occurred or reorganization is in progress.

6.3 Do target, limit, or threshold values already exist for the indicator?

[Fill by hand; if not in key results or implications, likely does not exist]

6.4 Have the indicators been tested to ensure they respond proportionally to a change in the underlying process?

[Fill by hand; if not in introduction, key results, or implications, likely not tested]

6.5 Are the indicators sensitive to a small change in the process, or what is the threshold of change that is detectable?

[Fill by hand; if not in introduction, key results, or implications, likely not tested]

6.6 Is there a time lag between the process change and the indicator change? How long?

[Fill by hand; if not in introduction, key results, or implications, likely not tested]

7 Comments

[Fill below by hand once above data complete]

7.2 What additional work would be needed for the Council to use the indicator?

7.3 What issues are caused if there is a gap or delay in data underlying the indicator